all news
Daily news Posts

Allegheny narrowly votes to reinstate Hyattsville

3.9. 2015 Written By: Gordon Houser 4,355 Times read

Allegheny Mennonite Conference (AMC) delegates met March 7 at Springs (Pa.) Mennonite Church and voted 72-70 to reinstate Hyattsville (Md.) Mennonite Church as voting members of the conference.

Later in the meeting, delegates released three congregations from membership in the conference.

In 2005, AMC delegates voted to keep Hyattsville as nonvoting members and to not allow members of the conference to hold elected positions in AMC or in Mennonite Church USA.

The reason for this, according to the 2005 resolution, was that Hyattsville had been found to be “inconsistent with the Membership Guidelines of Mennonite Church USA.”

Delegates had expressed concerns about the congregation’s membership practices, including the appointment of a person in a same-sex relationship as a delegate.

The new resolution stated that AMC “is willing to live together with theological disagreements, using the 1995 Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective as a guiding document, not a disciplinary document.”

Both the 2005 decision to sanction Hyattsville and the decision to reinstate them as full members were passed by a majority.

The decision to remove a congregation from membership requires a two-thirds majority vote, according to AMC leadership.

Mast Donna

Donna Mast

According to Donna Mast, AMC conference minister, the March 7 meeting was “civil [and] people were respectful.”

While there was laughter at various times throughout the day, she said in a March 8 phone interview, “the meeting was a sober one, made more so by the close vote.”

Three Maryland congregations—Glade Mennonite Church in Accident, Gortner Union Church in Oakland and Red Run Mennonite Church in Grantsville—submitted letters asking to be released from membership in AMC. Two of these letters had been submitted before the conference; Red Run’s was submitted after the vote, while delegates attended to other business.

Reasons for leaving had to do with differences about how to deal with same-sex relationships.
The resolution that passed also stated that “any congregation choosing to leave [AMC] as a result of this decision can request and receive assistance from the current Leadership Council in finding appropriate affiliation.”

This leaves AMC with 27 member congregations, two of which are church plants. Mast said the conference “will have to look hard at our structure,” which current giving patterns cannot sustain.

Cynthia Lapp

Cynthia Lapp

Cynthia Lapp, pastor of Hyattsville, said it is hard to know how to respond to the decision.

“It is obvious there are no winners here,” Lapp said in a March 8 email. “We have worked at building relationships for the past 10 years while we were under discipline. We will continue to work at building relationships for the next ten years as full members. We remain committed to praying with and for the conference as we move together into an unknown future.”

photo by Jake Short.

The Mennonite, Inc., is currently reviewing its Comments Policy. During this review, commenting on new articles is disabled; readers are encouraged to comment on new articles via The Mennonite’s Facebook page. Comments on older articles can continue to be submitted for review. Comments that were previously approved will still appear on older articles. To promote constructive dialogue, the editors of The Mennonite moderate all comments, and comments don’t appear until approved. Read our full Comments Policy before submitting a comment for approval.

7 Responses to “Allegheny narrowly votes to reinstate Hyattsville”

  1. Matthew Eshleman says:

    It’s amazing and disappointing that Hyattsville stayed a member for 10 years even under disciple and relegated to non-voting status, but the moment they were restored to membership 3 other congregations immediately left.

  2. Matthew Eshleman says:

    Previous comment should say discipline.

  3. BIll says:

    I am a Lutheran (ELCA) and we went through a similar issue in 2009. This article reflects in many ways the same sentiment found after the vote that allowed Pastor’s in same sex long term committed relationships to be called to serve in congregations of the ELCA. The repercussion’s are still being felt, but are diminishing with time. One must believe that the Holy Spirit is guiding us as Christians in all aspects of our faith and what that means to the communities in which we live.

  4. Elaine Mercer says:

    There was a lot of thoughtful discussion. Ben Wideman said that every congregation and every person emphasizes different aspects of the Confession of Faith; at the same time every congregation and person is at variance with other aspects. Another person who had helped write the Confession of Faith said it was never intended as a tool of discipline.

  5. […] prayer for one’s enemies, feeding the hungry and non-violent resistance. Reinstatement of the Hyattsville congregation by Alegheny Conference is a hopeful sign for […]

  6. Berry Friesen says:

    The Atlantic Monthly has published a long article about this meeting. It states that Conference leadership gave delegates three choices: “restoring Hyattsville to full membership, requiring a 51 percent majority to pass; removing Hyattsville from the conference, requiring a two-thirds majority to pass; or, if neither of those measures passed, dissolving the conference.”

    From a traditionalist perspective, those are all unhappy choices (the second because it was almost certain to fail). Why did Conference leadership not give delegates a choice that would have enabled all congregations to stay?

    And when such a choice was offered from the floor, why did it receive little support? I suspect delegates had a win/lose mentality, and one side won their bet and the other side lost theirs.

    Which takes me back to Conference leadership: why not legitimate compromise, rather than encourage win/lose thinking?

  7. Thomas says:

    A 72/70 vote indicates a lot of discord

Leave a Reply