all news
Daily news Posts

EB recommends keeping Membership Guidelines

2.3. 2015 Written By: Anna Groff, with information from an MC USA release 1,992 read

The Mennonite Church USA Executive Board (EB) met Jan. 29-31 in Kansas City, Mo., for a special meeting to plan for Kansas City 2015.

During this meeting, the EB voted to uphold A Shared Understanding of Church Leadership as a working document.

The document contains a statement taken from the membership guidelines about credential pastors not being able to perform same-sex unions.

Delegates are invited to review the document (details on how to access the document are coming) and give feedback during KC 2015 and over the course of the next two years, with the understanding that the document could be revised, in consultation with Mennonite Church Canada, by 2017.

After much discussion, the EB also recommended that the membership guidelines remain unchanged and be used as interpreted in the June 2014 action taken by the EB to Mountain States Mennonite Conference.

The EB noted that Mountain States Mennonite Conference and any other groups that would move to credential people in same-sex relationships would continue to be found at variance unless the Mennonite Church USA Delegate Assembly changes the stated policy on same-sex relationships.

Delegate survey
New for this assembly will be a delegate survey conducted prior to the assembly.

With input from the EB, Ervin Stutzman, executive director, is producing a set of questions for delegates, which will be available in the next week in English and Spanish.

“We think of this as a favor for delegates to know what the inclinations are on different issues,” said Stutzman on Jan. 31. “We want to make sure people are very well informed before they arrive.”

Gathering this kind of information in advance will also help the delegates and EB make the best use of their limited time.

“We will consider what we can manage in 18 hours of delegate sessions that will move us forward as a church,” said Elizabeth Soto Albrecht, moderator, on Jan. 31.

Polity change, not new structure
The restructure committee appointed by the EB in September 2014 reported that in their deliberations this fall, they found that there is not a structural change that would resolve the tensions in Mennonite Church USA, so they recommend maintaining the current structure.

In their report, the structure committee members wrote: “We also recommend that the board clarify, in consultation with the Delegate Assembly, its understanding of how ministerial credentials function in our system and how the EB understands its leadership function in relationship to area conferences and congregations.”

Soto Albrecht said the authority of the EB and the area conferences is a bigger question for Mennonite Church USA than the question of a new structure for Mennonite Church USA.

The committee members include Katherine Jameson Pitts, Isaac Villegas, Joy Sutter and Keith Weaver. Villegas and Sutter are EB members.

Meeting with ‘new network’
On Jan. 30, the EB met with Sunoko Lin, Matt Hamsher, James Wenger and Nahemiah (Nemi) Chigoji, representing a new network outside Mennonite Church USA and Anabaptist Renewal Circles.

“There was a sense of blessing them to find their voice and who they feel God is calling them to be, while holding the grief that we could not be faithful together,” said Soto Albrecht.

Stutzman has been relating to these two groups, he said.

“It is fluid. Some churches might remain within MC USA, they might join a new network and stay connected with [their] current conference or they might leave MC USA entirely,” he said.

During their meetings, the EB also received the resignation of board member Tyler Hartford, pastor of Pleasant View Mennonite Church in Goshen, Ind., due to other commitments, including a congregational assignment.

The Mennonite, Inc., is currently reviewing its Comments Policy. During this review, commenting on new articles is disabled; readers are encouraged to comment on new articles via The Mennonite’s Facebook page. Comments on older articles can continue to be submitted for review. Comments that were previously approved will still appear on older articles. To promote constructive dialogue, the editors of The Mennonite moderate all comments, and comments don’t appear until approved. Read our full Comments Policy before submitting a comment for approval.

2 Responses to “EB recommends keeping Membership Guidelines”

  1. Grant Martin says:

    These decisions by the EB Board truly amaze me. It seems that they are absolutely determined to let Mennonite Church USA fly apart before they realize that changes need to be made. It saddens me that they cannot take their heads out of the sand long enough to see the path of destruction they have our entire denomination on right now. They say they are listening to us, but I simply cannot see how they are when these are the decisions they make.

  2. […] became the 37th state to allow gay marriage–meanwhile, the Executive Board recommended maintaining the definition of traditional marriage through 2017. Wait, what […]

Leave a Reply