all news
Daily news Posts

MC USA, Bethel reach agreement on GCMC records

9.11. 2017 Written By: Hannah Heinzekehr, The Mennonite 455 Times read

Photo: Mennonite Library and Archives in North Newton, Kansas. Bethel College photo. 

Bethel College, North Newton, Kansas, and Mennonite Church USA have come to an agreement regarding the management of the records of the former General Conference Mennonite Church (GCMC), one of the predecessor denominations of Mennonite Church USA. In July, the two organizations finalized a memorandum of understanding that cedes ownership and management responsibility of the records to Bethel. The college is currently working to develop an endowment fund to help cover the ongoing costs of care for the records and the broader Mennonite Library and Archives on campus that the records are a part of.

As part of the merger process to form Mennonite Church USA, an agreement had been in place that MC USA would provide a subsidy, most recently for approximately $42,000 per year, to Bethel for the maintenance of the GCMC records. The subsidy helped subsidize the salaries of MLA archivists and to purchase supplies. Records from the Mennonite Church had been stored in the Newcomer Center on the Goshen (Indiana) College campus.

In 2016, MC USA made a decision to separate denominational records from Goshen College records and to relocate the MC USA records to a new space in the MC USA office building in Elkhart, Indiana,. At the same time, the previous memorandum of understanding between MC USA and Bethel expired.

According to Ervin Stutzman, executive director of MC USA, due to shrinking budgets, subsidies to care for the records in two separate locations were no longer feasible. Last fiscal year, MC USA reported a loss of over $230,000. Glen Guyton, chief operating officer of MC USA, says that staff managed reserves proactively to cover increased expenses during a convention year and are also making changes to account for new budget realities.

As part of the negotiations, denominational staff offered to move GCMC records from their current location to the new facility in Elkhart, but Bethel College staff preferred to keep the GCMC records onsite.

“For researchers and for our curricular needs at Bethel, the GCMC, Western District Conference and Bethel College records are so integrated it would have become very difficult for researchers to negotiate their work if they were moved,” said Robert Milliman, vice president for academic affairs at Bethel, in an Aug. 30 phone interview. “We consider this an important symbol on our campus of our commitment to MC USA. That was one of the reasons we didn’t want to see the records leave. We are committed to the denomination and certainly want to keep these records available to researchers and students.”

Despite the records now having different owners, Jason Kauffman, the director of the MC USA Archives, says he hopes to remain in conversation and to collaborate with Bethel archivist John Thiesen to support the work of researchers across the denomination.

To promote constructive dialogue, the editors of The Mennonite moderate all comments and comments don't appear until approved. Anonymous comments are not accepted. Writers must sign posts or log into Disqus with their first and last name. Read our full comment policy.

One Response to “MC USA, Bethel reach agreement on GCMC records”

  1. It’s too bad the Mennonite church has a waning interest in historical records and their collection, preservation and accessibility, not to say that Bethel will be an irresponsible custodian. With the demise of the denominational historical committee 10 years ago and the questionable but predictable social priorities of leaders such as Stutzman and Guyton and their absence of connection to the hub of the former GCMC in central Kansas, they aren’t going to want to keep paying for space at the MHA no matter how priceless (and as a sporadic user I testify that it is valuable beyond price tag). I hope funders who value the historiographical enterprise–and an honest one–will step up to help all our archives and libraries survive and thrive, even as one has to also be vigilant to make sure such new, more private or parochial owners and donors don’t serve merely partisan interests.

Leave a Reply