all opinions
Opinions posts

Fear, power and non-indictment in the murder of Tamir Rice

1.5. 2016 Written By: Joanna Harader 473 Times read

Joanna Harader is Pastor at Peace Mennonite Fellowship in Lawrence, Kan. This post originally appeared on her blog, Spacious Faith

Are we accountable for our fear?

This is a question that white people in particular need to consider.

Tamir Rice, a 12-year-old black boy, was shot to death on Nov. 22, 2014. On Dec. 28, 2015, a grand jury decided not to indict the white police officer who killed him. The primary reason given for the non-indictment is that the police officers “reasonably believed their lives were in danger.”

In other words, the police officers were scared. So the shooting was acceptable.

Except a dead boy in the park is not acceptable. Tamir laying there bleeding for four minutes while the police officers stood by is not acceptable. A grieving mother being told that her son’s death is nobody’s fault–simply a “perfect storm of human error”–is not acceptable.

But acceptable or not, because the officers were “reasonably” afraid, the jury determined that this was not a crime.

Are we accountable for our fear?

“Do not be afraid” is one of the most common statements in the Bible. God speaks these words to Abraham, Hagar, Isaac, Jacob, Moses, Joshua, Elijah, Hezekiah, the Israelites (multiple times), Zechariah, Joseph, Mary, the shepherds, the disciples, the crowds that gathered around Jesus, the women at the tomb, Paul and John of Patmos.

“Do not be afraid.”

We tend to read these as words of consolation. We imagine a gentle arm around the shoulder, a calm and sympathetic voice. “There, there. It’s OK. Don’t be afraid.”

We feel better when we read these words. But maybe we should feel worse. Because we are terribly fearful people. And what if these words are not consolation? What if these words are in reality what the ancient grammar suggests: commandments. Not gentle sympathy, but stern rebuke.

“Do not be afraid.”

The combination of fear and power is lethal. For black people, the combination of white fear and white power has proven deadly time and time again.

Are we accountable for our fear?

The grand jury for the Tamir Rice case said “no.”

But I think we are. I think we have to be. I think the more power we have, the more accountable we are for our fear—and for the damage we leave behind in the wake of our fear.

We may not be able to control our fear in the panic of the moment—we can’t untie the knot in our stomach or smooth out the goose bumps on our arms. But we can cultivate a life of fearlessness. We can take deep breaths and say deep prayers. We can befriend people who are different from us. We can examine our power and our privilege.

And we can love. Not a pop song love. A biblical love. The love of the incarnation which is solidarity with the outsiders. The perfect love that, according to the writer of 1 John, casts out fear.

We have to work harder to follow God’s repeated command: Do not be afraid. We see all around us the devastation that fear creates—not just the lifeless body of Tamir Rice and other victims of police shootings, but the mass shootings and terrorist attacks and political hate speech and…and…and…

Fear is deadly. And we are accountable for our fear and the death it causes. The more power we have, the more accountable we are.

May God have mercy and move us toward the perfect love that casts out fear.




This is a shortened version of an article that appeared in our March magazine. For full access to this article and others like it, check out our online edition

The Mennonite, Inc., is currently reviewing its Comments Policy. During this review, commenting on new articles is disabled; readers are encouraged to comment on new articles via The Mennonite’s Facebook page. Comments on older articles can continue to be submitted for review. Comments that were previously approved will still appear on older articles. To promote constructive dialogue, the editors of The Mennonite moderate all comments, and comments don’t appear until approved. Read our full Comments Policy before submitting a comment for approval.

One Response to “Fear, power and non-indictment in the murder of Tamir Rice”

  1. WJYoder says:

    Thanks, Pastor Harader.
    Yes, a true tragedy in the killing of 12-year-old Tamir Rice here in Ohio!
    The church needs to hold the government/police community accountable as it claims to keep us safe.

    We Mennonites are ever more taking action out of fear: protecting ourselves by accumulating excessive wealth and now the creeping reality , perhaps, of hand guns ownership. Now this I fear.

    I wish you had more clearly identified the “we” throughout this letter.