This is a web-exclusive article on the theme “God so loved the whole world.” For more stories on this theme, see the May issue of The […]
“What is a Pharisee anyway?”
I remember asking myself this question around the campfire at Mennonite summer camp. The question arose after singing this line: “I don’t want to be a Pharisee. I don’t want to be a Pharisee, cause they’re not fair you see. I don’t want to be a Pharisee.”
Since that time, I have learned Pharisees were the Jewish scribes and sages in 1st-century Palestine. They play a large role in the New Testament, often being cast as the ones with whom Jesus argues, even calling them a “brood of vipers” (Matthew 23:33). In the Christian narrative, Pharisees has been a stand in for anyone who is self-righteous and hypocritical. Matthew 23:2-3 says, “The Pharisees and the teachers of the Law are experts in the Law of Moses. So obey everything they teach you, but don’t do as they do. After all, they say one thing and do something else” (Contemporary English Version). Jesus, on the other hand, stands apart. He is loving, compassionate, and congruent in his actions and beliefs. He is the “way, the truth and the light”(John 14:6). This narrative became a key driver for the early church’s separation from Judaism and has continued to be a typology for Christianity’s exceptionalism.
Recently, I joined a synagogue with my partner, who is Jewish. Though I plan to remain connected to the Mennonite church in San Francisco, we will be raising our children in the Jewish tradition. It has been both a joy and a difficulty to begin to deepen into Jewish learning and practice. It is a joy because I feel the richness of Jewish thought and commentary bring alive in a new way the stories I learned in the context of the Old Testament. And it has been difficult to sit with the harm that has been done and continues to be done with the Christian narrative as the weapon.
I have learned that Judaism, as it is known and practiced today, very much identifies its roots with the Pharisees. They are regarded and revered as the forefathers who created and re-envisioned a tradition after their Temple was destroyed and the Jewish people were forced into exile. While Christians may think of the Pharisees as a long-lost Jewish sect, their lineage is very much alive in the Synagogue. As Jewish New Testament scholar Amy-Jill Lavine writes in Sojourners magazine, “Just as we are heirs of centuries of racism, we are heirs of two millennia of negative stereotypes of Pharisees and, by extension, of Jews—for it is substantially from Pharisaic teaching that rabbinic Judaism springs” (Quit Picking on the Pharisees). Lavine, with decades of deep relationship with Christians, begs us to realize that when we invoke the “Jesus vs. Pharisees” narrative, we cause harm.
This year Passover falls on Easter. It reminds me of Christianity’s overlapping history with Judaism. And this year I remember that anti-Semitism is on the rise, as well as all forms of bigotry and hatred. The anti-Semitic trope of Jews such as George Soros being the puppet masters and manipulators of the masses can be directly traced to nearly two millennia of Christian anti-Semitism that linked the Pharisees/Jews to the orchestration of Jesus’s death. This was what fueled the murder of 11 Jewish elders at the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh last October.
I assume most Christians have no intention of being anti-Semitic when speaking of the Pharisees. Certainly I did not mean to be anti-Semitic when singing songs around the campfire at Mennonite summer camp, but I was.
When putting the New Testament polemics against the Pharisees into context, I can see that Christians and Pharisees were caught in chaotic times. Both groups were fighting fiercely for identity under the crushing domination and occupation of the Roman Empire. The making of enemies and the struggle against them is certainly a key part of any individual’s or group’s quest towards identity. However, the narratives that we rely on for individuation and identity are often overly simplistic and leave out any sense of nuance. When a group like Christians manages to wed itself with power and empire, these narratives quickly become deadly.
After sitting though Shabbat services for the past two years, embarking in Jewish learning and beginning the very difficult, tedious and rewarding task of learning Hebrew and the Talmud (a collection of commentaries by scribes and sages/Pharisees from 200 B.C. to A.D. 600), I feel I am finally learning the question I asked as a child, “What is Pharisee anyway?”
The Pharisees, heard through the pages of the Talmud, are becoming my teachers and my friends. They created and preserved a beautiful tradition, one in which I find great solace and intellectual engagement. Sometimes the Pharisees, like any good friend, partner or therapist, confuse and annoy me. They do not create simple narratives and, for this reason, they help me grow. Even in our own Christian texts I find proof that the Pharisees have more complexity than often remembered. Luke credits the Pharisees with warning Jesus of his impending arrest (Luke 31:3) and reports that Jesus and the Pharisees ate with one another (Luke 11:37). Sure, they debated and disagreed during this meal, but after reading one line of the Talmud, I can see that arguing was (and still is), an embedded practice between all Jewish teachers, rabbis and sages, including Jesus.
In finding the flexibility and exceptions to the simplistic narratives I was given as a child, there is opportunity to mature. As I unpack and learn the most painful parts of Jewish/Christian history, and as I remember my days at summer camp unconsciously singing, “I don’t want to be a Pharisee,” I feel it is only by the grace of God, and perhaps the Pharisees, that I find myself in this place of healing, growth and learning.
Addie Liechty is a psychotherapist, singer-songwriter and writer of poetry and essays living in the Bay Area of California. Addie grew up in Indianapolis and attended Goshen (Indiana) College for their bachelor’s degree and Smith College for their master’s of social work. Their writing interests include the intersections of spirituality, religion, psychology and social justice.
The Mennonite, Inc., is currently reviewing its Comments Policy. During this review, commenting on new articles is disabled. Comments that were previously approved will still appear. Comments on older articles can continue to be submitted for review in accordance with the policy below. To promote constructive dialogue, the editors of The Mennonite moderate all comments and comments don’t appear until approved. Anonymous comments are not accepted. Writers must sign posts or log into Disqus with their first and last name. Read our full Comments Policy.